Dynasty Fantasy Football vs. Redraft – 5 Reasons Why the Long-Term Game is Better
Fantasy football is endlessly popular with sports fans. The NFL in general is still the best league to follow, so it only makes sense that the “fake” side of the game is growing almost daily.
The love for creating fake rosters of real dudes scoring fake points is growing, but despite the affection sent fantasy football’s way, there is an argument brewing.
The debate at hand? What’s better between dynasty fantasy football and the redraft format? It’s highly subjective, and every person can have a different answer. Once you start factoring in league size, scoring settings, and more, it becomes one big, hot mess.
Even so, I think I have the answer; dynasty fantasy football is better than redraft fantasy football. Not sold so easily? Dive into the dynasty vs. redraft debate with my five reasons why the long-term option is superior.
1. Dynasty Fantasy Football Isn’t Over After One Season
Maybe you think that’s a big perk about redraft leagues. Perhaps you prefer to draft your team, enjoy the season, and start all over again.
Hell, if you have a crappy draft, I feel you. However, you might just have another bad draft next season. Maybe the season after that it’s even worse, and it’s always possible you’re just bad at this whole drafting thang.
Whatever the case, dynasty fantasy football gives you multiple outs. You can stink up the joint in year one, adapt to your league, and come out with a fury in year two and beyond.
If you want more than the one-league thrill, latch onto a long-term project and join a dynasty fantasy football league.
2. Trades Mean So Much More
The best thing about dynasty fantasy football has to be trading. As I mentioned, if you didn’t draft well – and maybe even if you did – you can always make your team better by trading with your league mates.
What’s the difference between dynasty fantasy football trades and trading in redraft?
Prospects mean more, and future draft picks have major value.
You won’t trade picks the same way in regular fantasy football leagues (or at all, possibly), while young players have far less value unless they turn into studs immediately.
Trading is a fun game within the game, too. Interacting with your league and making big trades creates buzz within the league, it drums up excitement for your team, and gives you something extra to think about when it comes to roster construction.
3. League Engagement is Felt More
I don’t know about you, but there’s nothing worse than a dormant fantasy football league. I’ve been in countless leagues where managers are incredibly absent.
This leads to lineups not being set, players not being added or dropped when they should be, and a general lack of enthusiasm permeating throughout the league.
Here’s a checklist for a successful fantasy football league:
- Play with people who care
- Make sure you also care
- Play dynasty football
I kid, I kid. But really, if you’re in a league with even one person who stops caring, it weighs the league down.
In dynasty formats, nobody is truly out of the running until the playoffs roll around, and with trades and future picks on the table, there’s always extra incentive to stay dialed in.
4. You Can Maintain League Continuity & Chemistry
Worried about having managers in your fantasy football league that will bolt at the first sign of a struggle? Starting a dynasty league can negate that.
As noted, trades, picks, and young prospects all being prevalent can keep even the worst fantasy manager involved. And if they leave their team to be an orphan? This format is growing in popularity so rapidly that you won’t find that much trouble finding a suitable replacement.
You can’t guarantee those types of people won’t threaten your dynasty fantasy league’s environment. However, this type of league puts up barriers to protect leagues from getting boring. You just need to piece together the proper settings and rules to build a strong foundation.
Should You Play Dynasty Fantasy Football or Redraft Fantasy Football?
The most honest answer? Both. I’d also try IDP and every other form of fantasy football you can get your hands on. They’re all worth a shot, and you can sprinkle little changes in like Auction drafts, FAAB bidding for free agents, and the list goes on.
However, if you want to settle the debate of dynasty fantasy football vs. redraft fantasy football, I’m rolling with the long-term option.
Dynasty fantasy football puts you in the driver seat as your fake team’s GM. You draft the initial team, you make the calls at future rookie drafts, and you decide how to proceed with trades.
You have full control in this type of league, and it gives you every single thing redraft leagues offer, and so much more. The only remaining questions are where to play dynasty fantasy football, and what dynasty fantasy football strategy is best.
But that’s for another day. For now, test out all kinds of leagues, and if you haven’t tried dynasty fantasy football yet, I definitely suggest you do so.
Writer at Daily Fantasy Fade
DFS Keanu has been covering fantasy sports, DFS, and props for the better part of a decade, all while fighting The Matrix and a litany of assassins.
Latest posts by DFS Keanu (see all)
- NFL DFS Sleepers for Week 2 – Best Values at DraftKings - September 13, 2024
- Week 2 NFL DFS Picks – Top Plays at DraftKings - September 13, 2024
- NFL DFS Showdown Picks for Week 1 TNF - September 4, 2024
